Egg Donors

thankful woman
Pros and Cons of Using a Friend or Family Member as a Surrogate or Egg Donor

Pros and Cons of Using a Friend or Family Member as a Surrogate or Egg Donor

The decision to involve a friend or family member as a surrogate or egg donor in the journey of surrogacy or egg donation presents unique advantages and challenges. This article explores the pros and cons of such arrangements.

On the positive side, using a friend or family member can be more cost-efficient, allowing for lower compensation or even altruistic assistance. Additionally, maintaining genetic familiarity and preserving familial traits can offer a sense of continuity for future generations. Furthermore, the emotional bond shared with a loved one during this transformative experience can strengthen relationships and provide a valuable support system. However, there are potential drawbacks to consider. The intimate nature of these journeys may risk straining or complicating close relationships. Surrogacy, with its medical and legal complexities, can become even more intricate when involving a friend or family member. Similarly, using a family member's eggs in egg donation raises questions about genetic similarity and its impact on family dynamics. To navigate these challenges, professional guidance and clear communication are vital. Utilizing the services of an agency or fertility concierge can facilitate open dialogue and ensure the preservation of precious relationships. By carefully weighing the pros and cons and embracing effective navigation strategies, couples and individuals can embark on these journeys with greater confidence, fostering a supportive family environment while preserving cherished connections.


The journey of finding a surrogate or an egg donor for surrogacy or egg donation can be a complex and emotional one, filled with both excitement and uncertainty. In recent years, the availability of surrogates has become increasingly challenging due to a shortage of surrogates in the US. In light of this, one important decision to make is whether to involve a friend or family member as the surrogate or egg donor. While this choice has its advantages, it also comes with its own set of considerations. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using a friend or family member as a surrogate or egg donor.


1. Cost Efficiency:

One significant advantage of involving a friend or family member as a surrogate or egg donor is the potential for cost savings. Friends and family members may be more willing to charge a lower compensation or even offer their services altruistically, which can significantly reduce the financial burden associated with assisted reproductive technologies.

2. Genetic Familiarity: The Importance of a Genetic Family Tree in Egg Donation

In the realm of egg donation, the significance of a genetic family tree cannot be overstated. Opting to use a friend or family member as an egg donor grants you the invaluable advantage of having access to detailed genetic information. This allows you to establish and maintain a direct familial genetic connection, thereby preserving your family's unique genetic traits for generations to come. The awareness of this continuity not only brings comfort but also fosters a profound sense of connection and continuity as you embark on the journey of building your family through the incredible act of egg donation.

3. Emotional Bond:

Embarking on the surrogacy or egg donation journey with someone you deeply care about can create a unique emotional bond. Sharing this transformative experience with a friend or family member can bring you closer together, strengthening your relationship and fostering a strong support system throughout the process.


1. Risking Close Relationships:

The surrogacy and egg donation journeys are highly emotional and sensitive, and it's essential to consider the potential impact on your relationship with a friend or family member. The intensity of the process, including hormone injections, medical procedures, and legal agreements, can strain even the closest of relationships. It is crucial to evaluate whether you are willing to risk the potential strain or complexities that may arise during and after the journey.

2. Complexities in Surrogacy:

Surrogacy involves a lengthy and intricate process that includes medical interventions and legal considerations. When a close relationship is involved, it can introduce additional complexities. Navigating the intricacies of surrogacy with a friend or family member may require clear boundaries, open communication, and careful management of expectations to ensure a smooth journey for all parties involved.

3. Genetic Similarity:

To ensure a thoughtful approach to the dynamics of using a friend or family member's eggs in egg donation, it is crucial to consider how open you will be with your future child about their donor conception. We firmly believe in maintaining open communication with the child, as advised by mental health professionals, as hiding such information can lead to potential challenges in the future. With this in mind, it becomes essential to reflect on how both you and your child would navigate the potential emotional complexities arising from the child closely resembling their genetic donor. While sharing this unique connection can be extraordinary, it is important to weigh these considerations and determine how it aligns with your vision of family dynamics and the long-term well-being of your child.

4. Navigating the Journey:

Regardless of whether you choose to involve a friend or family member as a surrogate or egg donor, it is advisable to seek professional assistance from an agency or a fertility concierge. These experts can provide guidance, support, and facilitate open communication throughout the process. Their involvement can help ensure that your relationship with your friend or family member continues to thrive after the journey, minimising any potential strains or misunderstandings.

5. Addressing Uncomfortable Situations

Ask yourself: What happens if, for any reason, the journey fails? For example, if you had multiple implantations and the journey doesn't achieve pregnancy, or if your friend or family member changes her mind and wants to stop the journey or move on with another intended parent. There may be moments when you feel uncomfortable, and when it is someone close to you, these situations and emotions are amplified.

It is important to have open and honest conversations with your potential surrogate or egg donor, setting expectations and discussing potential outcomes. Consider the possibility of a backup plan or alternative arrangements in case the journey doesn't progress as intended. Remember, open communication and mutual understanding are crucial for navigating any challenges that may arise during this deeply personal and complex process.

By acknowledging and discussing these potential cons with your friend or family member, you can establish a solid foundation for your surrogacy or egg donation journey. Professional guidance from agencies or fertility concierges can also help you navigate these delicate situations with clarity, support, and open communication.

Remember, the decision to involve a friend or family member as a surrogate or egg donor should be made after careful consideration of all the pros and cons. Ultimately, the most important factor is creating an environment of trust, understanding, and mutual respect between all parties involved. With the right support and guidance, you can navigate the challenges and complexities of this journey while preserving and strengthening your cherished relationships.

Need our advice?

We understand that navigating the complexities of using a friend or family member as a surrogate or egg donor can be overwhelming. Our team is here to support you. Contact our head of care for a free consultation.

We're dedicated to providing guidance and assistance to help you make informed decisions and ensure a smooth and fulfilling journey towards building your family. Don't hesitate to reach out and take the first step towards realising your dreams of parenthood.

You may also like

All Stories